All articles

ChatGPT vs Legal AI: What Fits a Law Firm or Notary Office

· 5 min read

Use both, for different jobs. ChatGPT is good for generic text, ideas and explanations. A legal AI tool built around your files is a better fit for client work, because it answers from your own documents and shows the page.

Many lawyers and notaries already use a general chatbot. Others are asking whether they need a dedicated tool. This article compares the two without hype, so you can decide what to use for what.

What is ChatGPT good at?

A general chatbot is strong at work that does not depend on your files:

  • Generic drafting. A first version of a blog post, a polite email, a meeting agenda or a job ad.
  • Brainstorming. Ways to structure an argument, questions to ask a client, titles for a talk.
  • Explaining. A plain explanation of a concept, or a summary of a text you paste in.
  • Rewriting. Shorter, clearer or friendlier versions of a paragraph.

For these tasks it is fast, cheap and flexible. You do not need a special tool for them.

Where does a chatbot fall short for an office?

The gaps show up when the work is about a specific client and a specific file.

  • It does not know your files. Unless you paste text in, it has never seen the deed, the contract or the email chain. Pasting 200 pages is slow and often not possible.
  • Answers come without a source page. A fluent answer is not proof. If you cannot see where a fact comes from, you must find it yourself, and then the time saving is gone.
  • There is no shared workspace. Each person has their own chats. Colleagues cannot see the same documents or build on each other's questions.
  • Client data sits in a personal account. The office has little control over who has access, what is kept and how to remove it.
  • It does not use your templates. It writes text. It does not fill your own Word template, with your layout and your numbering, from the facts in a file.

None of this makes a chatbot bad. It was built to be general. An office needs something built around its own documents.

What does a legal AI tool add?

A tool built for law firms and notary offices starts from your files instead of a blank chat. Using Acta as the example, it adds:

  • Answers from your documents, with the page. Ask a question about a case and get an answer with the exact page it comes from, so you can check it in seconds.
  • Your own Word templates. Drafting fills your templates and shows the source of each proposed value, such as the case, a note or a document and page.
  • A workspace per office. Everyone in the office works on the same documents. The data is private to that workspace.
  • Anonymization. Personal data is found and hidden, and you review what was removed before you share the result.
  • Translation that keeps the layout. Tables, headings and numbering stay close to the original.
  • Work organized by case and client. Documents, drafts and appointments sit where the team expects them.

A fair point: Acta also uses OpenAI's models underneath. The AI is not magic and it is not a different brain. The difference is the workspace around it: your documents, the sources, your templates and the office's control over its data.

How do they compare side by side?

| | General chatbot | Tool built around your files | |---|---|---| | Generic text and ideas | Very good | Good | | Knows your documents | Only what you paste | Yes, in the workspace | | Shows the source page | No | Yes | | Shared by the whole office | No, personal chats | Yes, one workspace | | Uses your Word templates | No | Yes | | Anonymization and translation with layout | No | Yes | | Control over client data | Depends on the account | Set by the office | | Price | Check the current plans | Check the vendor |

What should you check before choosing either?

Ask the same questions of every tool, including the one you already use.

  1. Where is the data processed? Ask for the country of the servers and the names of the companies involved, such as the AI provider and the email service.
  2. Who are the subprocessors? A serious vendor lists them plainly. If you cannot find the list, ask.
  3. Are sources shown? You need to see the document and page behind an answer.
  4. Can the office export and delete its data? You should be able to take your files out and remove them when you leave.
  5. Who can see client data? Check whether your content is used to train models, who inside the vendor can read it and how long it is kept. For ChatGPT, read the current terms for your plan, because they change.
  6. What does it cost? Look at the real price for your team, including extra users.

Also check what your bar or chamber says about AI and client confidentiality. This article is general information, not legal advice. Follow your bar's or chamber's guidance.

Which one should you pick?

It depends on the job, not on a single winner.

Use a general chatbot for text that has no client data in it: a newsletter, a template for a cover letter, a way to explain a concept. Keep client names and confidential facts out of a personal account.

Use a tool built around your files for client work: finding a clause in a long file, drafting from a deed, filling your templates, anonymizing before you share, translating a document for a foreign client. These jobs need your documents, a source for each fact and a workspace the whole office shares.

Whatever you use, the rule is the same. The AI proposes and you check. Read the result as if a junior colleague wrote it. If the tool shows the source, the check takes seconds. If it does not, do not rely on it.

Where Acta fits

Acta is a web app for notary offices and law firms. Ask Acta answers questions from your own documents and shows the page each answer comes from. Drafting fills your own Word templates with the source of each value. Anonymization lets you review what was hidden, and Translation keeps the layout. Each office has its own workspace, and its data is private to it. Acta runs on a server in Germany and uses OpenAI's models. Acta is free during the pilot. To see it on your own kind of file, request a demo.

Frequently asked questions

Can lawyers use ChatGPT for client work?
It can help with generic text, ideas and explanations. For client work, first check your bar's guidance and the current terms of your plan, and keep confidential facts out of a personal account. Always check the result yourself.
Is a legal AI tool just ChatGPT with a different name?
Not exactly. Some tools use the same kind of models underneath, Acta included. What differs is the workspace around the model: your documents, the source page for each answer, your own templates and the office's control over its data.
What is the best AI for a small law firm?
There is no single best tool. A small firm often does well with a chatbot for generic text and a tool built around its own files for client work. Judge each by sources shown, data handling, templates and price.
Does a chatbot show where its answer comes from?
A general chatbot usually does not point to a page in your documents, because it has not seen them unless you paste them in. A tool that searches your own files can show the document and page behind each answer.
What should I ask a vendor about client data?
Ask where the data is processed, which companies process it, whether it is used to train models, who can read it, and whether you can export and delete it. A serious vendor answers these plainly.

Written by Ala Baganne, software engineer and founder of Acta.

About the author

See what Acta can do for your office

Tell me which tasks take your office the most time, and I’ll tailor a free demo to them.

Request a demo